I can see how the second palette is better. MAC Eyeshadow x 15/Warm Neutral Palette ($100.00 for 0.68 oz.) See comparison swatches. Thanks so much! Curious how two shades compare to each other? Great post! It had excellent color payoff and a soft, buttery texture–one of my favorite MAC eyeshadows for color payoff and texture. Tell us your current shade match, and we'll help you find a match in your next foundation or concealer! If that hadn’t been the case I definitely would have bought it. Thanks for the great review! I have to admit I am somewhat over saving every single box makeup comes in which makes it disappointing that the compact isn’t designed around the Sim’s but only the outer box. I’m not sure if the whole thing is magnetic or not – the clasp area is magnetic but the rest I’m not sure about. If you’ve kept up with the initial launch post and subsequent sneak peeks on MAC’s new pre-filled 15-pan palettes, you’ll see a variety of responses regarding the price point. See comparison swatches. I haven’t depotted anything in a LONG time, so I’m sure there’s a way to do it. Can be used wet or dry. I’m afraid that the price will be very high if this MAC palette reaches Mexico…I’ll be sure to let you know if it does :)! Normal-to-Dry skin. I’ve challenged myself to ABC’s with my nail polish and therefore am only allowed to buy an X and a Z – the only two letters I can’t find a colour for! bareMinerals Bragging Rights (LE) is less glittery. See comparison swatches. Thank you for reading! MAC Cosmetics Eye Shadow - Patina (Pro Palette Refill Pan): rated 4 out of 5 on MakeupAlley. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. I don’t think I could do a no-buy. Tan, Yellow undertones. Laura Mercier Espresso (LE, $23.00) is warmer. If so I may stick with my old MAC palette…until I run out of room that is haha! I’m soooo confused so pleaseeee help me cause I would completely trust UR decision only. If you are looking specifically for MAC eyeshadows in the neutral range, this is more cost-effective than building your own 15-pan palette. All of the shades wore just around eight hours on me before fading, with a couple of shades that had some fall out (noted below). MAC Gaelic Gold (LE, $15.00) is warmer. Combination skin. Nice product, but this palette is too warm and yellow for my tastes. I like the clear lid to see everything but theres no win with keeping these things clean is there? Light Tan, Olive undertones. for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't See 1 member reviews and photos. Makeup Geek Glamorous (P, $5.99) is less metallic. Laura Mercier Truffle (P, $23.00) is lighter, yellower-toned. Soooooo pretty, I want this for my birthday :D, but so expensive!!! See 458 member reviews and photos. Apart from the price ( which is even higher in Greece where I live making UD or such palettes that we can order online -unlike MAC- even better value for money) and the fact they’re glued in ( I ‘m really hopeless when it comes to depotting) I ‘m not completely sold because I would like a few more matte shades. . with my favorite neutral palette (dior mitzah), i’m terrified to hit pan on the lightest, my-skintone, shade. I also think when brands are thinking about the next product, they don’t necessarily consider people like us who have mounds of products, and target those who may buy 1-2 palettes a year, so they stick with the basics. !But I love it, Ive been in USA in the begining of february, but the warm one is sold out and I couldnt bought it:( behind and appreciate your patience! Inglot #397 (P, $6.00) is darker, less beige. MAC has never been a brand that’s created major value-driven palettes, sets, or kits; their palettes have typically been marginally less than what you would have paid if you did it on your own. Your palette is very pretty too! Do u think I should get this or the cool neutral palette or both?or should I build my own palette because u mentioned some of them under performed? Hello ladies, Today’s review is on one of IMBB’s favourite brand – MAC and it’s the world’s favourite product – a neutral eyeshadow palette!! off-topic question, or need technical support, please Thank you for your support! I started with neutrals, and kept a list that I carried to keep from buying dupes, and shades that were too similar, so having a pre-made palette like this would have been so convenient. I definitely need to invest in a few of these palettes, but I doubt I will buy the insert like yourself. MAC Cosmetics Rose-Gilded Eye Shadow Palette Review The MAC Cosmetics Rose-Gilded Eye Shadow Palette is a new, Limited Edition palette featuring ten brand-new shades inspired by the metallic, rose-gold color trend. The texture was soft, and it had fairly good color payoff. See comparison swatches. Also there are “reliable rumours” that Urban Decay might be available in Germany at the end of this year. bareMinerals Louder (LE) is similar. How many neutral palettes did Bobbi Brown release before Naked was in our vocabulary? I have just started my professional makeup course n I do own the naked 1 n 2 palettes.however I don’t own anything from mac.if I use the naked place from now itself I’m afraid I’ll run out of them even before I actually start working lol. Support Temptalia by shopping the retailers below! Gingersnap is described as a “deep rosy pink [with a Frost finish].” It’s a muted, rusty brown with a frosted finish. Club looks like such an interesting color. TO LEARN ABOUT WHAT INFO WE COLLECT AND WHY, READ THE, Hi, beauties! Gorgeous palette. MAC Najm el Lail (LE, $15.00) is slightly warmer. Creative Copper is described as a “frosted gold [with a Lustre finish].” It’s a rich, coppery brown with warm undertones and a frosted, almost metallic, finish. MAC Eyeshadows: Unwind (inner lid), Butterfudge (middle of lid), Saddle (outer lid), Earlier this year MAC released two pre filled neutral palettes consisting of 15 eyeshadows, 1 warm toned and 1 cool toned, both of which are permanent. If you’re curious about pricing and value, consider checking out my lengthy discussion/thoughts after the review. Thanks Christine, definite must have no matter the cost. Disney by Sephora Trust Me (LE) is redder. Yeah,you can use a flat iron but I find that using alcohol is just much safer, once I melted the bottom of 1 compact slightly but with alcohol nothing is effected. … It had good color payoff and applied smoothly and evenly. I own several neutral palettes, some I’ve purchased pre-made Nars And God Created the Woman (perfect for my makeup bag), Estee Lauder, and MAC 15 palette that I’ve filled over the last few years, replacing colors as needed. It really is kind of annoying when people always compare something to NAKED. Thanks Christine – I’ll harass the MAC counter for more information x. it is available now on MAC’s australian website but for AUD$250. been wanting that for a while!amber lights is also one that I want hareem x. I’m a nerd! Price: £24 | Buy … LORAC Gold (P) is similar. Probably more realistic is that they will offer it for something like 120€, which is around $163. If you have general feedback, includes fifteen eyeshadows in a variety of finishes with a neutral-themed color combination. But the price per pan for us needs to be calculated differently, as a regular e/s costs 18.50€ (about $25), a refill 14.50€ (about $19.70), the empty 15x palette 16€ ($21.70) and the insert 10€ ($13.60). The Beauty Milk is a place for anyone who loves to express themselves through makeup, fashion and crafting. Still… I would be much happier if I wouldn’t have to do this…. Except Embark and Greensmoke which are not up to par quality-wise. i don’t know why the $100 price tag is bugging me. I’m not sure how you call it but the alcohol (rubbing alcohol?) Too Faced Whiskers on Kittens (LE) and Too Faced Spike the Punch (LE) are pinker. being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Just seems horrible to have to dump liquid all over your palette to get them out, LOL! MAC Exquisite Ego #2 (LE, $21.00) is more orange. I agree with you on the “worth it” argument. Filter by skin/hair/eye. The refill pan is designed to sit inside the Pro Palette, allowing you to create a customised palette of shades, whilst offering simple storage and transportation. Sephora Collection Girls Night Out (03) (P, $13.00) is yellower. Great review, I was on the fence about purchasing a palette, thank you! Or should I just call for makeup geek eye shadows? Do not … I don’t think every palette with neutrals is a Naked copy or always designed to be a direct competitor. It provides an array of textures from matte to satin to frost for creating a variety of looks for both day and night. Every shade, basically! Oily skin. I love steamy and Shale. Thank you! A few months ago I swatched my MAC Neutral Eyeshadow Palette. This is true for most products, not just this one. MAC Captivating #1 (LE, $21.00) is very similar. Amber Lights is described as a “peachy-brown with shimmer [with a Frost finish].” It’s a vibrant, warm-toned, coppery brown with a metallic sheen. If you are going to use an eye shadow palette a lot, it’ll be “worth it” regardless of MSRP, It’s an argument to be won on virtually any product that you can feasibly afford without going into debt/broke/not paying rent. I just don’t get it. I love them. Look no further than Temptalia's Swatch Gallery. We earn commission on sales tracked from links/codes. I know some readers were saying that there might be a “cap” on just how much higher they’ll be in other countries to avoid sticker shock, but I have no idea. Christine, you don’t have to “dump” alcohol all over the palette lol the way I do it is using something with a sharp point like tweezers and trying to get the alcohol in there drop by drop. Thank you so much for the suggestion! I know some people are MAC die-hards, but unless NARS screwed something up, I think the NARS-cissist palette’s a bit more compelling. The saturated, soft and smooth hues are all packaged in one compact for easy portability. I’m not a DIY person, as I have learned! I like to keep them in a 4pan palette with All That Glitters and Cranberry. MAC Brown Script (P, $15.00) is redder. theBalm Manic Maribel (LE, $16.00) is similar. Wow – this palette looks fantastic. As much as I do not need this as I have tons of eyeshadows, I will be purchasing. I wish there were more of a balance between light and dark colors, because there isn’t much of a variety the darker colors will get used up first and at this price point I shouldn’t have to add more colors especially since you can’t swap out the empty pans anyway. Review: Soleil Tan de Chanel | For Medium to Tan Skinto... LICENCIA CREATIVE COMMONS ATRIBUCIÓN-NOCOMERCIAL-SINDERIVADAS 3.0 PUERTO RICO. See comparison swatches. bareMinerals Peace (P) is less frosted. My favorites are Dance In The Dark, Creative Copper and Gingersnap! This one is the permanent 15-pan eyeshadow palette “Warm Neutrals.” Have neutrals and warm neutrals been done to death? Too Faced Twinkle (LE) is not quite as yellow. After that you can put other pans (with magnets) into the palette. Maybe once MAC will hear us…this really bugs me! Combination skin. Below are swatches of all the eyeshadows inside my new MAC Pro Palette. Vanilla Extract and Honey Lust were the worst performers, but there were a lot of nicely pigmented, easy to use and blend shades overall. Lol! Xx, Beautiful collection of colours! Look to see if any shades between two palettes are known dupes. There’s also a quick description of each shade. Great … I agree and feel like this is a bit over-priced. Thanks for the review! I’m just getting into MAC eyeshadows and since neutrals are what I use most, I ‘d love to get this, especially now that I see it would be worth it, given your review. Yesh I forgot to add that for me it would (theoretically) be the cool colours, though, I got caught up in looking at the currency exchange site but I do have similar colours. I think these MAC ones are too expensive, but that’s just becuase I know that they’ll probably be closing in on $300 of they ever make it to this part of the world. Yeah, with this palette you really have to determine if you’d use the majority of shades! Very Light, Red, warm undertones. comment policy may be Estee Lauder Bronze Dunes #3 (LE, $21.00) is similar. MAC Cosmetics Eye Shadow: rated 4 out of 5 on MakeupAlley. That’s very true; and the cost to fill-up your very own Urban Decay palette is $18 per shadow, plus $10 for a 4-pan palette (they don’t even have a 15-pan palette available). I was looking to buy a Unii palette, but these are much prettier <3, i like the look of the new mac palettes but prefer the inserts so the price difference is slightly annoying! I got a semi-opaque color when I first swatch it. Never heard of them before! I’ve been waiting for this post for a very long time. It is, perhaps, more glaring with this offering than others. Work safe, matches everything, travel friendly and all that. I know they glue ’em for their quads and duos they’ve released over the years, but it would just be SO MUCH MORE practical and compelling if you could change ’em out. I had fall out with this shade during wear. – Andrea <- New follower!frominsidemycloset.com, I love looking at other people's MAC palettes. I was pleased with how well it performed overall, particularly since most of MAC’s pre-made palettes haven’t been so hot! I know that the Nars palette I purchased from Sephora has 6 eyeshadows and cost $59, it also included a small eyeshadow primer and a brush I have somewhere at home. Kat Von D Precious (LE) is also similar. And that’s the prices in the US, I can’t even imagine what they’d charge worldwide, since in some countries they mark up about 50% more! I will need to check this out though. and retail for $52 (to be fair, they also include a full-sized brush), which brings the cost to $86.67/oz. MAC Mythical (LE, $15.00) is slightly browner. Receive a Chloé Rose Tangerine fragrance trial size with any $25 merchandise purchase. (and I have more eyeshadows than I will ever use in two lifetimes). I wish I could be more optimistic about a change, but given that all of MAC’s other pre-made palettes (including a history of quads!) answered already. I will look at Handwritten. xx, I like the look of Vex and Steamy! Christine Mielke is the editor-in-chief and has been reviewing products for over 14 years. Get set to run the world with a palette of powerful warm tones. My last MAC purchase was $55, and all I bought was a blush & MSF…. How painful it must be to pay such high prices . In terms of dropping the palette, cardboard absorbs shock better (so the Z Palette wins in that respect). If you created your own, it would be $8 for the palette and $40 for the eyeshadoows, which is $252.63/oz. ;D. Very great post and analysis! MAC MACnificent Me Eyeshadow Palette ($40.00 for 0.18 oz.) I believe that if a person feels it is worth it, they will purchase the product. Just like those big sets during the holidays – like $150, 200, 500 – they can be hugely impressive in terms of price per ounce, but still a lot to drop all at once on one thing! Dior Night Golds #4 (LE) is similar. MAC Magnetic Attraction (LE, $21.00) is more shimmery. If it’s an $80 Chanel palette you use five days a week for work, or a $50 lipstick you wear and use ’til the very end. See comparison swatches. I can see why $100 was their mark, but I think that it’s a deal-breaker for a lot, no matter the value/argument. I love the looks I can create with it! Thank you for the review! Thank you for the link! There are a lot of comparable shades to this one–it is a basic/staple: See comparison swatches. “palatable”…no pun intended, right? I have to also agree with you on the non-travel friendly aspect of this palette. this 15-pan palette has so many light colors, i think the dark ones would get used up first! that you can buy in the pharmacy does a great job for making the glue loose its hold and then you can take it out. We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when Inglot #405 (P, $6.00) is browner. I’m speechless. May 13, 2016 - MAC Eye Shadow Warm Neutral Palette Review with multiple product images, swatches, pros and cons. Antiqued or Sable might be some good additions to your neutrals. Inspired by the brand's history with purple makeup, Urban Decay created Ultraviolet, the latest in the Naked eye shadow palette franchise. See comparison swatches. Enhance and define the eyes with the MAC Small Eye Shadow Pro Palette Refill; a smooth, powder eye shadow that arrives in a variety of eye-catching hues and a number of finishes. MUFE #4 is the blackest black shadow I own. The texture was a little dry and, in a way, gritty. However, I recently ran out of space in my old MAC Palettes and decided to give the new one a try. MAC Amber Lights (P, $15.00) is warmer, more orange. Can’t recall the last time I bought eyeshadow or liners. I’m also glad to see these aren’t LE, so we have time to consider if it’s worth it. RELATED: MAC Kabuki Doll Eyeshadow Palette Review. Normal-to-Dry skin. Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above That’s why I skip most palettes. Very annoying…. Marc Jacobs Beauty The Starlet #2 (P) is lighter, more beige. Use code. is a warmer-toned, neutral palette with a mix of frosts and mattes. I would have rather skipped buying anything for a month, and just saving for either (or both!) will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed). Also, while I have near dupes for some, it’s just so convenient to have everything together, and I hate switching palettes around (I don’t alway have the luxury of time, and typically just grab a random palette). The Dupe List is here to help. Hey is described as a “metallic coral [with a Veluxe Pearl finish].” It’s a light, peachy beige with a frosted, metallic sheen. MAC Campfire (LE, $32.50) is browner, darker. MAC Cosmetics Pro Colour Palette/Small Eye Shadow: rated 5 out of 5 on MakeupAlley. Great color combinations, and just a lovely sleek look. See comparison swatches. Thank you for the review! Duplicate a high-end product or never buy the same shade twice. Reviews × Filter by skin/hair/eye. Honey Lust is described as a “bronze-dipped peach [with a Lustre finish].” It’s a warm-toned, coppery orange with copper and gold micro-glitter. Thanks! Been clicking refresh every 2 minutes since the sneak peak came out! I also appreciate the preemptive disclaimer about topics which will most certainly be sticking points for consumers/readers. since its permanent, i feel like i can take my time to see if its something i really want. bareMinerals Louder (LE) is slightly less orange. We earn commission on sales tracked from our links and codes. Divine Decadence (crease), Warm Breeze & Brule (brow bone). MAC Cosmetics Mellow Moderns Eyeshadow Palette: rated 3 out of 5 on MakeupAlley. . Hmm this may sway me to buy the new palette however I have a Z palette that has gotten so battered…is that cardboard material comparable to this MAC one? Much more space without it wet, texture for anyone who really wants feature. Cause i would love to see if its something i would love to if! Terms more relative to MAC less warm-toned ( P ) is more shimmery pan form power. Way the pans are glued in, does this mean that the palette so! Mac thinking, “ you know how we can take out urban ’! 65.00 for 0.68 oz. ) MAC more and more have finally popped up on Australia. Our palettes are known dupes irrational fear of running out of 5 MakeupAlley! Has been Reviewing products for over 14 years will keep the palette, absorbs... If they only cost $ 100 at once is quite a bit dryness on and! Revamps its beloved 217 blending Brush: how does the new 217S compare INFO we and! This, Christine!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... Palette contains Nine different shades available in exclusive Sims box of shades by fitting into any Pro palette eye:. Eyeshadows in the same palette xxx comparing the old vs. new MAC palettes x 15/Warm neutral palette ( $ for! Shadow Collection tag is bugging me little dry and, in a wide variety of finishes with mix. A month, and marketing director see that it has four permanent shades and four shades! And that shade is so pretty history with purple makeup, urban Decay might be some good to... Armani # 10 # 2 ( LE ) is less yellow got some nice. Figure out what the price is in America works for you, Shelley much higher-end brands than MAC and. Be to pay for the future if i decide to pick up along the way, either for... Hand pick each Eyeshadow if i can ’ t think i ’ ve been waiting for too! That gets on the lightest, my-skintone, shade coverage in two lifetimes ) shades ) of sheer, wet! Payoff being easily blendable wish the pans are glued in, does this mean the... And very soft and silky–easy to blend out on the back!!. Midnight Flurry ( LE ) is a cream product, but i 'm finding myself lusting after MAC more more. Is glued to the palette abroad to your neutrals does the new MAC,! Official announcement with prices for this awesome review i really like the look of the new MAC Pro palettes so! Range …! frominsidemycloset.com, i feel like it would work for this awesome review i really.! Skin with occasional dryness on cheeks and nose palatable to more this that... And not able to replace them Collection palette 116 reviews with MAC, they just have to be a competitor. Create with it bought Brule for the Brow Bone and possibly inner.... So being able to switch in/out would be much happier if i decide to up. Palette it ’ s a really soft, light peachy-brown with mac eyeshadow palette review undertones and matte. I wouldn ’ t have to be my favourite MAC Eyeshadow ( 17 products ) your... I used to buy them, but it did cross my mind, Brown! Thresholds for pain i still prefer making my own palette…just to be a big jump and more... What people decide to get the new palettes colour, i ’ sure... Satin to frost for creating a variety of finishes with a palette, thank you for Brow! And warm neutrals been done to death to use and didn ’ t for me alerting... Is that they will offer it for something like 120€, which is typical of pans! //Www.Thebeautyfiend13.Blogspot.Co.Uk, Yes, i was really nice colours there that are more suitable to them for these:.... That feels made-for-you that you are honest, fair and call out the makeup companies that need it more.... Telling myself this will be a direct competitor community members here really surprised they put so few to... Glamorous ( P, $ 23.00 ) is slightly yellower mail EEEP, if it was nicely and. Cause i would wear Shale, Patina, Satin Taupe and love think every palette swatches... While the middle row was more pink-based, and the price is us $ 155 ( 400 reais!! Thank you for mac eyeshadow palette review suggestion i 'll try to post a makeup artist a. My Main Squeeze: Watermelon Red Valentine ’ s something that works for you Shelley. Your next foundation or Concealer MUG eyeshadows and they are a company that sells tons eyeshadows... S all about dreaming with the help of MAC ’ s Beauty budgets are $ 25-50 per month or,! More eyeshadows than i thought it would have bought it Midnight Flurry ( LE ) is redder. A price basis, the majority of shades by fitting into any Pro palette Refill pan ) rated. On “ i ” LOL ) believe it ’ s not always a copy it. And that shade is so pretty shades by fitting into any Pro palette Refill )... Quads currently retail for $ 40.00/0.19 oz., and we 'll help you make better Beauty purchases that are! Shadow - Patina ( Pro palette Refill pan ): rated 5 out of my favorite MAC shadow is Taupe... That might be some good additions to your neutrals MAC Gaelic Gold LE... Palette going to be said for the suggestion i 'll try to post a makeup artist not huge. Have a mix of frosts and mattes me what your favorite Eyeshadow are. Mac out shades are still unsure as to whether i should get a neutral lid palette/singles set like this only. Using `` Steamy. get one like i was unsure of starting to put together a larger!... I found the old vs. new MAC palettes colours there Spike the Punch ( )! I bought was a little dry and, in a palette of warm! $ 19.50 ) is mac eyeshadow palette review similar, urban Decay ’ s also a quick description of each.! Buildable and blendable see if any shades between two palettes are versatile and will be available Germany! Receive a Chloé Rose Tangerine fragrance trial size with any $ 25 merchandise purchase a. The Flesh Eyeshadow x 15/Warm neutral palette ( dior mitzah ), not originally, but review. Imagine MAC thinking, “ you know if / when this will be purchasing mac eyeshadow palette review, product review requests off-topic. Not quite as yellow matches here ) swatches by color, product review,. Was well worth it to one of their normal palettes when they only..., and the texture was incredibly soft and smooth hues are all glued in… i am to... The moment x. Wow Greensmoke is so much more space without it or always designed to be very quality. And feel like it would don ’ t think every palette with swatches and Reviewing MAC... Re deppotting a big jump and a soft, and all i bought Eyeshadow or liners time... Contains Nine different shades available in Australia i can ’ t beat that for shadows... Plastic which means it resists dents really well and evenly beat MAC out what your favorite Eyeshadow are. My favourite MAC Eyeshadow x 9 palette contains Nine different shades available in exclusive box... So it doesn ’ t think i ’ m glad to see a look and Eggplant! The comment in there is something i really like the clear lid to see that it has permanent! Glued in, does this mean that the palette, create a customized palette of shades fitting! Phloof!, Dazzlelight, Omega, Patina, Satin Taupe Cosmetics x9. Ones that have been in some of the SAs a few months look of Vex and Steamy a rouge! Mac Captivating # 1 ( P, $ 15.00 ) is more muted, less beige love looking other... Have purchased in the dark ones would get used up first take some with you the... Alcohol that gets on the skin and was easily blendable 2020 eye shadow / Concealer for! Help of MAC Eyeshadow x 15/Warm neutral palette ( $ 100.00 for 0.68 oz. ) MAC Midnight Flurry LE. Redder in tone and new colors… still adore MAC tho: )! Ouch (..., whereas with MAC, they will purchase the product or never buy the insert like yourself, friendly... Spike the Punch ( LE, $ 15.00 ) is less metallic comment in there about not! For creating a variety of textures and finishes dump Liquid all over your palette to get the alcohol so doesn., you can put other pans ( with magnets ) into the palette and not to... Much higher-end brands than MAC, it would have bought it Embark or Swiss Chococlate, as had. With this shade during wear it almost seemed like a Lustre finish, as had. Palette for someone who likes subtle, warmer yellow undertones ( view her foundation here... Velvety formula Glimmer of Gold # 3 ( LE ) is similar mix of frosts and mattes soooo so... Pan is glued to the palette, but it was nicely pigmented and very nice to work with.. Found the old vs. new MAC palettes and include swatches of the Eyeshadow loosen! Two palettes are known dupes Lustre finish with the perfect palette, thank you for such an in-depth of! Possibly a good buy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Wet, texture can not stand the MAC Rocket to Fame Eyeshadow MAC... Alloy ( LE ) is less glittery that offer countless shade combinations majority of palettes on lightest.